Did I Make the Right Decision?

The question that comes back when everything gets quiet

Did I make the right decision?

If you’ve asked yourself that question after your divorce, you are not alone.

And I’m not talking only about the first few weeks, when everything is raw and you’re trying to work out what happened.

I’m talking about months later. Maybe years later.

You’re having a perfectly ordinary Tuesday. You’re making dinner. You’re driving somewhere. You’re scrolling through your phone. And suddenly that little voice shows up.

What if I was wrong? What if I should have stayed? What if my children would have been happier if I’d tried harder? What if I never find anyone else? What if this was the best I was ever going to get?

That part can be incredibly hard because leaving is one decision. Living with the decision is another thing entirely.

Sometimes we think that if we were certain, we’d never look back.

Real life doesn’t work that way.

You can know why you left and still miss parts of what you had. You can be relieved and sad in the same week. You can know a marriage wasn’t working and still wonder what might have happened if you’d done one more thing differently.

None of those feelings automatically mean you made the wrong decision.

Why doubt doesn’t necessarily mean regret

Doubt gets a bad reputation.

We often treat doubt as proof that we’ve made a mistake. But doubt can simply mean that the decision mattered.

Divorce changes practical things, emotional things and family routines. You may lose a home, friends, money, traditions, a familiar identity and the future you thought you were going to have.

Of course your mind goes back and checks the decision.

It is looking for safety.

The problem starts when you keep reopening the same case without any new evidence.

You remember the good weekend but forget the months of tension. You remember the family holiday but forget how you felt when you were alone together. You remember the person you hoped your partner would become and compare that person with the life you have now.

That’s not a fair comparison.

When you are lonely, the past can look much shinier than it actually was.

Ask yourself a different question: If nothing about the marriage had changed, would I have wanted to live the next ten years exactly as I was living then?

That question can tell you more than asking whether you miss someone.

The children question can make everything harder

For mothers, there is often another layer.

What did this do to my children?

You may worry about their sadness, anger or disappointment. You may replay arguments and wonder whether you could have protected them better.

There may be things you wish you had handled differently. That’s normal. You are allowed to acknowledge mistakes without deciding that the entire divorce was a mistake.

Children can struggle with divorce and still be okay.

They may need time. They may be angry. They may blame you for a while. They may later understand things differently.

Your job isn’t to manufacture a perfect childhood. None of us can do that.

Your job is to keep showing up, listen when you can, hold reasonable boundaries and give them a relationship with you that is honest and steady.

You don’t have to spend the rest of your life punishing yourself because your family changed.

Stop putting your old marriage on trial

At some point, you have to stop asking the past to give you a different answer.

You can learn from it. You can admit what you did wrong. You can admit what your former partner did wrong. You can grieve what you lost.

But you cannot keep going back to court every night in your head.

Try writing two lists.

On the first: What I genuinely miss. On the second: What I do not miss.

Be specific.

Maybe you miss having someone to call when something funny happened. Maybe you miss family dinners. Maybe you miss the house, the routine or simply knowing what tomorrow looked like.

On the other list, write what was painful, exhausting or unacceptable.

Look at both lists.

This is a fuller picture than either nostalgia or anger on its own.

The question that matters now

Eventually the better question becomes: What do I want my life to look like now?

Not what should my life have looked like. Not what would impress other people. Not what would make your divorce look justified.

Your life now.

You may not have the answer yet. That’s okay.

Start small.

What would make your mornings better? Who makes you feel good to be around? What kind of work would give you a sense of purpose? What do you want to learn? Where do you want to travel? What would financial stability look like? What kind of relationship would you accept now, if you ever decide to date again?

Divorce may have taken you somewhere you didn’t plan to go. That doesn’t mean the rest of your life has to be an accident.

You don’t need to prove that leaving was the best decision anyone ever made.

You just need to stop abandoning yourself because you are afraid it wasn’t.

Maybe the decision wasn’t perfect. Maybe you weren’t perfect.

You don’t need either of those things to build a good life.

You need honesty.

And then you need to start living.

A few questions to sit with

Before you close this article, ask yourself:

What do I actually miss, and what am I romanticising? What did I know then that I keep forgetting now? If nothing had changed, would I want another ten years of that marriage? What have I learned about myself? What do I want to do differently in the next chapter?

You don’t have to answer all of them tonight.

Just start telling yourself the truth.

Continue Reading